CD, e-mail, cloud or image sharing? Sharing channels compared
How should a CBCT, CT or MR reach the referring doctor and the patient? The options compared, six typical mistakes from practice, and what to ask a provider.
The channels in one table
| Channel | Speed | Encryption | Logging | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CD / DVD | slow, days | usually none | none | lost, scratched, no drive at the recipient |
| USB stick | medium | rarely | none | lost, may carry malware |
| fast, but small files only | partial | none | wrong recipient, size limit | |
| Consumer cloud storage | fast | in transit | limited | no data-processing agreement, never-expiring links |
| Hospital PACS | fast (inside) | yes | yes | hard to open to outside doctors |
| Health-care image sharing service | fast | yes | yes | choosing the right provider |
The table shows general characteristics; individual products differ. The question is not which one is “perfect”, but which lets you meet the legal requirements: a data-processing agreement, encryption, personal access, logging, retention.
Six typical mistakes
- Wrong recipient. E-mail autocomplete picks another colleague.
- Password in the same e-mail. The password of an encrypted file travels with the file.
- Never-expiring link. A share link with no expiry and no revocation, still working years later.
- Telling file name. “Smith_John_1965_CBCT.zip” in a folder many people can see.
- Lost media. An unencrypted USB stick or CD in the post, in a bag, in a car.
- Shared account. One login for the whole practice: the log is meaningless and former staff still have access.
Each of these can be a personal data breach that, if it involves a risk, must be reported to the supervisory authority within 72 hours.
What to ask an image-sharing provider
- Will they sign a data-processing agreement (GDPR Art. 28), and who are their sub-processors?
- Where are the servers (inside the EU?), and is data encrypted at rest as well?
- Are there personal accounts, strong authentication (e.g. passkeys, two-step login) and roles?
- Can the practice see who opened a study and when?
- How does a patient link identify the patient — does it expire, can it be revoked?
- Is the original DICOM kept and downloadable?
- Does it handle different vendors’ formats (CBCT, CT, MR, slice series, compressed DICOM, whole CDs)?
- Are there off-site backups, and are restores tested?
- What happens to the data at the end of the service — is the full archive handed over in a readable form?
- Is there a written incident procedure, and how fast is the practice notified?
Tip: keep it simple for referring doctors — if recipients have to install a program or pay for an account, they will go back to CDs.
Frequently asked questions
Is a CD a secure way to pass on imaging studies?
Not really: it is usually unencrypted and not logged, it can be lost, and recipients often have no drive or suitable viewer. It also does not guarantee readability over a long retention period.
May I use personal Dropbox or Google Drive to send studies?
Not recommended for health data: these services typically do not sign an individual data-processing agreement with the practice, and share links often never expire.
Is a password-protected ZIP file enough?
Only if the password is given through a separate channel (e.g. by phone). It still does not log opening, and the file can spread further at the recipient.
What should I do if I sent a study to the wrong recipient?
Ask the recipient to delete it, record the incident and assess the risk. If it involves a risk, report it to the supervisory authority within 72 hours.